Here are the five most-visited poems in the poetry blog, since its inception, with numbers of visits and posting dates:
Prayer for the World 110 19 Jul 2017 (expressly placed into the public domain)
Arcanum Zero, the Fool (Ad Hoc I) 96 30 Sep 2017
Rumer 84 8 Oct 2017
I Will Be Guided 82 13 Oct 2017
Happy Birthday 79 5 Oct 2016
In general, I agree with your choices, though I think Arcanum Zero made the list because of wishful thinking (on your part, and on mine). Prayer for the World is the only poem, if I'm not mistaken, that I've placed into the public domain, so I obviously like it. Rumer is one of my favorites. I Will Be Guided is the only one on the list written by my alter ego, Nagna Devidas. Happy Birthday, the only poem not written in 2017, was written on my mother's birthday in 2015, and posted when the blog was started, in Oct 2016. For a long time no poem in the blog exceeded it in number of visits, but as the blog's readership grows, the numbers are getting bigger.
As a holiday gift, I'll re-post all five of these poems today. You needn't thank me; it is I who need to thank you, for your wonderful support.